Let’s Talk small vessels noise emissions

Share Let’s Talk small vessels noise emissions on Facebook Share Let’s Talk small vessels noise emissions on Twitter Share Let’s Talk small vessels noise emissions on Linkedin Email Let’s Talk small vessels noise emissions link

Consultation has concluded

Background: Vessel engine noise emissions

The Small Vessel Regulations currently require that all power-driven vessels be equipped with a muffler. This requirement helps make sure that the engine noise from power-driven vessels is limited to avoid disturbing the environment and others using the waterway.

While a muffler is required, the regulations don’t include any performance standards for mufflers or engine noise emission limits.

These gaps have led to concerns that vessel engine noise sometimes exceeds acceptable levels. Police have also noted that it’s hard to enforce the current requirements as they lack the technical expertise needed to identify whether a muffler is properly equipped or not.

Transport Canada is looking at several ways to address these concerns.

Proposed options

Option 1: Make no changes

This option would not add any new regulatory requirements.

Considerations:

  • No additional cost to industry or police
  • Vessels could continue to be built and operate at excessive noise levels
  • Police would continue to face challenges identifying whether vessels comply with the Small Vessel Regulations
  • No incentive for industry to build quieter vessels

Option 2: Clarify and modernize existing requirements

This option would update the Small Vessel Regulations to clarify existing requirements, for example, more descriptive technical specifications for mufflers.

Considerations:

  • Clarifying current requirements could help the police identify whether a vessel complies with the Small Vessel Regulations (For example, is a vessel equipped with a muffler?)
  • No additional cost to industry or police
  • Proposed changes would not address vessels that comply with the regulations but still produce excessive noise
  • Proposed changes don’t consider future technologies that could address engine noise

Option 3: Introduce performance standards for manufacturers to follow

This option would update the Small Vessel Regulations to require companies that make and import pleasure craft to test their vessels to make sure their engine noise does not exceed set noise-emission levels.

Considerations:

  • Could be a cost-neutral solution for industry who already do similar testing for vessels in other markets
  • Would make sure that new vessels don’t exceed engine noise-emission levels
  • Would not apply to existing vessels whose engine produces excessive noise
  • Would be hard for police to check whether vessels have been properly tested

Option 4: Introduce performance standards for vessel operators to follow

This option would add engine noise-emission limits to the Small Vessel Regulations. It would also ban vessels from being used in a way that exceeds noise-emission limits when tested according to set standards.

Considerations:

  • Police could more easily identify whether a vessel complies with the regulations
  • No additional cost or requirements to industry
  • Police would need to buy equipment to measure noise levels and train officers on how to use it
  • Vessel operators who comply with the current regulations may need to modify their vessels to meet new requirements

Option 5: Introduce performance standards for manufacturers and vessel operators to follow

This option would combine Options 3 and 4. It would update the Small Vessel Regulations so both manufacturers and operators must make sure their vessels don’t exceed noise-emission levels.

Considerations:

  • Proposed changes would make sure that new and existing vessels don’t exceed noise-emission levels
  • Police could more easily identify whether a vessel complies with the regulations
  • Police would need to buy equipment to measure noise levels and train officers on how to use it
  • Vessel operators who comply with the current regulations may need to modify their vessels to meet new requirements

We want to hear from you

  1. Choose “Register” at the top of the page, and join the discussion under the “Have Your Say” tab
  2. You can also submit your comments in a Word or PDF document through the “Submissions” tab (one or more documents can be uploaded)

Background: Vessel engine noise emissions

The Small Vessel Regulations currently require that all power-driven vessels be equipped with a muffler. This requirement helps make sure that the engine noise from power-driven vessels is limited to avoid disturbing the environment and others using the waterway.

While a muffler is required, the regulations don’t include any performance standards for mufflers or engine noise emission limits.

These gaps have led to concerns that vessel engine noise sometimes exceeds acceptable levels. Police have also noted that it’s hard to enforce the current requirements as they lack the technical expertise needed to identify whether a muffler is properly equipped or not.

Transport Canada is looking at several ways to address these concerns.

Proposed options

Option 1: Make no changes

This option would not add any new regulatory requirements.

Considerations:

  • No additional cost to industry or police
  • Vessels could continue to be built and operate at excessive noise levels
  • Police would continue to face challenges identifying whether vessels comply with the Small Vessel Regulations
  • No incentive for industry to build quieter vessels

Option 2: Clarify and modernize existing requirements

This option would update the Small Vessel Regulations to clarify existing requirements, for example, more descriptive technical specifications for mufflers.

Considerations:

  • Clarifying current requirements could help the police identify whether a vessel complies with the Small Vessel Regulations (For example, is a vessel equipped with a muffler?)
  • No additional cost to industry or police
  • Proposed changes would not address vessels that comply with the regulations but still produce excessive noise
  • Proposed changes don’t consider future technologies that could address engine noise

Option 3: Introduce performance standards for manufacturers to follow

This option would update the Small Vessel Regulations to require companies that make and import pleasure craft to test their vessels to make sure their engine noise does not exceed set noise-emission levels.

Considerations:

  • Could be a cost-neutral solution for industry who already do similar testing for vessels in other markets
  • Would make sure that new vessels don’t exceed engine noise-emission levels
  • Would not apply to existing vessels whose engine produces excessive noise
  • Would be hard for police to check whether vessels have been properly tested

Option 4: Introduce performance standards for vessel operators to follow

This option would add engine noise-emission limits to the Small Vessel Regulations. It would also ban vessels from being used in a way that exceeds noise-emission limits when tested according to set standards.

Considerations:

  • Police could more easily identify whether a vessel complies with the regulations
  • No additional cost or requirements to industry
  • Police would need to buy equipment to measure noise levels and train officers on how to use it
  • Vessel operators who comply with the current regulations may need to modify their vessels to meet new requirements

Option 5: Introduce performance standards for manufacturers and vessel operators to follow

This option would combine Options 3 and 4. It would update the Small Vessel Regulations so both manufacturers and operators must make sure their vessels don’t exceed noise-emission levels.

Considerations:

  • Proposed changes would make sure that new and existing vessels don’t exceed noise-emission levels
  • Police could more easily identify whether a vessel complies with the regulations
  • Police would need to buy equipment to measure noise levels and train officers on how to use it
  • Vessel operators who comply with the current regulations may need to modify their vessels to meet new requirements

We want to hear from you

  1. Choose “Register” at the top of the page, and join the discussion under the “Have Your Say” tab
  2. You can also submit your comments in a Word or PDF document through the “Submissions” tab (one or more documents can be uploaded)
Discussions: All (6) Open (0)

  • What do you think about not making any changes, and not further addressing small vessel noise emissions?

    almost 3 years ago
    Share What do you think about not making any changes, and not further addressing small vessel noise emissions? on Facebook Share What do you think about not making any changes, and not further addressing small vessel noise emissions? on Twitter Share What do you think about not making any changes, and not further addressing small vessel noise emissions? on Linkedin Email What do you think about not making any changes, and not further addressing small vessel noise emissions? link
    625 Responses
    CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.

    You need to be signed in to add your comment.

  • What do you think about updating and changing the Small Vessel Regulations’ definition of a “muffler”?

    almost 3 years ago
    Share What do you think about updating and changing the Small Vessel Regulations’ definition of a “muffler”? on Facebook Share What do you think about updating and changing the Small Vessel Regulations’ definition of a “muffler”? on Twitter Share What do you think about updating and changing the Small Vessel Regulations’ definition of a “muffler”? on Linkedin Email What do you think about updating and changing the Small Vessel Regulations’ definition of a “muffler”? link
    187 Responses
    CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.

    You need to be signed in to add your comment.

  • What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers to follow? These standards would make sure new vessels are tested to confirm that they don’t exceed certain decibel limits.

    almost 3 years ago
    Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers to follow? These standards would make sure new vessels are tested to confirm that they don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Facebook Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers to follow? These standards would make sure new vessels are tested to confirm that they don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Twitter Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers to follow? These standards would make sure new vessels are tested to confirm that they don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Linkedin Email What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers to follow? These standards would make sure new vessels are tested to confirm that they don’t exceed certain decibel limits. link
    225 Responses
    CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.

    You need to be signed in to add your comment.

  • What do you think about introducing performance standards for vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels already in operation don’t exceed certain decibel limits.

    almost 3 years ago
    Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels already in operation don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Facebook Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels already in operation don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Twitter Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels already in operation don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Linkedin Email What do you think about introducing performance standards for vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels already in operation don’t exceed certain decibel limits. link
    181 Responses
    CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.

    You need to be signed in to add your comment.

  • What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers and vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels don’t exceed certain decibel limits.

    almost 3 years ago
    Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers and vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Facebook Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers and vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Twitter Share What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers and vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels don’t exceed certain decibel limits. on Linkedin Email What do you think about introducing performance standards for manufacturers and vessel operators to follow? These standards would make sure vessels don’t exceed certain decibel limits. link
    689 Responses
    CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.

    You need to be signed in to add your comment.

  • Are there any other steps you think should be taken to address vessel engine noise emissions?

    almost 3 years ago
    Share Are there any other steps you think should be taken to address vessel engine noise emissions? on Facebook Share Are there any other steps you think should be taken to address vessel engine noise emissions? on Twitter Share Are there any other steps you think should be taken to address vessel engine noise emissions? on Linkedin Email Are there any other steps you think should be taken to address vessel engine noise emissions? link
    169 Responses
    CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.

    You need to be signed in to add your comment.